Makeup · Eyeliner
Wet n Wild Breakup Proof: Fine Brush, but Will the Pen Skip?
In this guide
Product links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
A liquid liner can look promising until the tip skips during your second eye or releases too much ink at the corner. Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner puts a fine brush inside a pen, while Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner uses a separate bottle and applicator. Choosing between them starts with the way you like to draw, how carefully you cap your liner, and how much patience you have for touchups after the first line dries.
Which Breakup Proof pen are you buying?
This guide covers Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner in Black, the original liquid pen identified by the brand as model 1111509. Its current US description specifies an ultra-fine brush tip. A flexible brush is the useful detail here: the tip and the amount of pressure both matter when moving from a narrow line to a thicker stroke.
The family name also appears on Skinny, Wing Out and other eyeliner formats. Check the full product name and the picture before ordering a replacement. A review of a different tip does not tell you how this original pen will handle. Likewise, choosing Black here does not establish a shade match with another brand's darkest liner.
The original pen houses its liquid supply inside the barrel. Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner instead has an applicator that comes out of a small bottle. That changes the drawing routine: one stays together in your hand; the other asks you to manage the open bottle and return the applicator to it.
The appeal is the fine brush; flow is the tradeoff
Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner makes sense if you want to draw with a pen rather than dip a separate applicator. The brand describes a tank delivery system, but that does not mean every pen will dispense perfectly throughout its life. Think about whether you enjoy a flexible brush before treating the waterproof name as the whole buying decision.
In Allure's June 2025 eyeliner roundup, Houston makeup artist Rose Siard praises the original liner's ease and staying power. The article also suggests letting a layer dry before adding another. That is an attributed recommendation, not a promise that your line will survive every combination of tears, oil and rubbing.
US shopper experiences help explain the compromise. On Ulta's original Black pen page, Briana from Pennsylvania describes crisp, easy application. Alani from Arizona reports the pen drying after a few uses and touchups lifting the line; Trin from Virginia reports leaking and tip fraying. These are individual experiences, not a failure rate. They make flow and cap care worth considering before buying several backups.
Original brush pen or separate bottle?
Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner is a useful alternative when you prefer lifting an applicator from a bottle. Its US directions suggest connecting small dots along the upper lash line. Neither format removes the need to practice, and neither waterproof label establishes that it will outlast the other on your eyelids.
| Buying question | Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner | Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner |
|---|---|---|
| Format | Liquid held inside a capped pen | Separate bottle and removable applicator |
| Application preference | Fine brush with line width changed by pressure | Dip applicator; build a line with short strokes or connected dots |
| Routine detail | Shake, close the cap tightly and store tip down | Return the applicator to its bottle after use |
| Tradeoff to consider | Individual reports describe drying, leaking or fraying | An open bottle adds a separate piece to manage |
| Exact option here | Original Black single pen, model 1111509 | 251 Blackest Black single 0.08 fl oz bottle |
Choose the pen for the drawing format, rather than assuming it is automatically easier for beginners. Choose the bottle if a separate applicator already fits your routine. For a closer look at that option, read our Revlon bottle buying guide; for broader browsing, see the makeup category.
Use pressure carefully, then protect the tip
For Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner, follow the brand's sequence: shake before use, glide along the lash line with light pressure for a fine line, and increase pressure for a bolder result. A short stroke gives you a smaller area to assess before continuing across the lid. If you add another layer, let the first one dry instead of repeatedly dragging through wet liquid.
Replace the cap tightly and store the pen tip down, as directed. Line up the cap before closing it so the brush can enter cleanly. A damaged or persistently leaking tip is a practical reason to reconsider the pen, rather than repeatedly forcing it through the same stroke. Do not add water or other liquid to revive the formula.
With Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner, Revlon's US instructions offer the connected-dot approach for a thin upper-lash line. Start with the format you can control comfortably, then judge the dried result before adding thickness.
Frequently asked questions
Is the original pen a brush or felt tip?
The current US brand listing describes Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner as an ultra-fine brush tip. Check that you are buying the original pen rather than a differently named family member.
Does waterproof mean it cannot smudge?
No. Shopper reports vary, and a waterproof description does not guarantee resistance to every kind of moisture or rubbing. Assess your own dried line before depending on it for a long event.
What should I do if the pen starts skipping?
Check that you have followed the shake, tight-cap and tip-down storage directions. Avoid repeatedly scraping the brush over a drying line or adding liquid to the pen.
Is the bottle alternative the same product as its pen?
No. Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner here is the separate bottle in 251 Blackest Black. A similarly named pen, Skinny or Micro Easy version has a different identity and applicator.
Verdict
Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner is worth considering for its original fine-brush pen format if you like varying line width with pressure and will follow its capping and storage directions. The meaningful caution is inconsistent flow: individual users report both crisp results and drying or leaking. Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner is the alternative for someone who prefers a separate bottle and applicator. Pick the drawing routine that suits you, check the exact version, and judge wear on your own lids before relying on the waterproof name.
More to explore: Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner: Is the Bottle for You? · Maybelline Lash Sensational vs Sky High: Fan or Length? · NYX Epic Ink vs Epic Wear: Liner Pen or Brush-On Liquid?